The species that has the same number of electrons as 35 17 Cl is

The species that has the same number of electrons as 3517Cl is

<sup>32</sup><sub>16</sub>S
<sup>34</sup><sub>16</sub>S<sup>+</sup>
<sup>40</sup><sub>18</sub>Ar<sup>+</sup>
<sup>35</sup><sub>16</sub>S<sup>2-</sup>
This question was previously asked in
UPSC NDA-2 – 2017
The number of electrons in a neutral atom is equal to its atomic number (the subscript). For an ion, the number of electrons is adjusted based on the charge.
The species is 3517Cl. The atomic number is 17, so a neutral Chlorine atom has 17 protons and 17 electrons. We need to find the species with 17 electrons.
A) 3216S: Atomic number 16. Neutral Sulfur has 16 electrons.
B) 3416S+: Atomic number 16. Neutral Sulfur has 16 electrons. S⁺ means it lost 1 electron (16 – 1 = 15 electrons).
C) 4018Ar+: Atomic number 18. Neutral Argon has 18 electrons. Ar⁺ means it lost 1 electron (18 – 1 = 17 electrons).
D) 3516S2-: Atomic number 16. Neutral Sulfur has 16 electrons. S²⁻ means it gained 2 electrons (16 + 2 = 18 electrons).
Therefore, 4018Ar+ has 17 electrons, the same number as neutral 3517Cl. These species are isoelectronic.
The superscript number (mass number) is the sum of protons and neutrons and is irrelevant to the number of electrons in this calculation, unless isotopes are being considered, which is not the case here for electron count. The subscript number is the atomic number, which is crucial as it determines the number of protons and thus the number of electrons in a neutral atom.