The boss said to his secretary, “Did you discuss this matter with the manager?”

The boss asked his secretary whether he discussed that matter with the manager.
The boss asked his secretary if you have discussed that matter with the manager.
The boss asked his secretary if he had discussed that matter with the manager.
The boss asked his secretary if he has discussed that matter with the manager.

The correct answer is: C. The boss asked his secretary if he had discussed that matter with the manager.

The boss is using the past tense “discussed” because he is asking about a past event. He is not asking if the secretary has discussed the matter with the manager yet, but if he did discuss it in the past.

Option A is incorrect because the boss is not asking if he discussed the matter with the manager, but if he did discuss it.

Option B is incorrect because the boss is not asking if the secretary has discussed the matter with the manager, but if he did discuss it.

Option D is incorrect because the boss is not asking if the secretary has discussed the matter with the manager yet, but if he did discuss it in the past.

Exit mobile version