A right circular cylinder of height 10 cm and circular base of radius 5 cm is filled to half of its capacity by water. The cylinder is tilted so that no water goes out of the cylinder. The angle from the vertical by which the cylinder is tilted is
not more than 30Β°
not more than 45Β°
more than 45Β°, but not more than 60Β°
not less than 60Β°
Answer is Wrong!
Answer is Right!
This question was previously asked in
UPSC CISF-AC-EXE β 2020
Let the height of the cylinder be H = 10 cm and the radius of the base be R = 5 cm.
The volume of the cylinder is $V_{cyl} = \pi R^2 H$.
The cylinder is filled to half its capacity with water, so the volume of water is $V_{water} = V_{cyl} / 2 = \pi R^2 (H/2)$.
When the cylinder is upright, the water level is at height H/2 = 10/2 = 5 cm.
When the cylinder is tilted by an angle $\theta$ from the vertical, the water surface remains horizontal. Water will start spilling out when the horizontal water surface reaches the rim of the cylinder.
When the cylinder is tilted to the maximum possible angle $\theta_{max}$ without spilling, the horizontal water surface must pass through the lowest point on the base rim and the highest point on the top rim. These two points are diametrically opposite when viewed along the direction perpendicular to the tilt axis.
Consider a vertical cross-section of the cylinder along a diameter perpendicular to the tilt axis. This cross-section is a rectangle of width 2R and height H.
The lowest point on the base rim in this cross-section is at one corner (say, position -R, height 0). The highest point on the top rim on the diametrically opposite side is at the other corner (position +R, height H).
The horizontal water surface, when the cylinder is tilted to $\theta_{max}$ without spilling (and containing half the volume), forms a plane that cuts this cross-section along a line segment from (-R, 0) to (R, H) *in the coordinate system aligned with the cylinderβs base diameter and height*.
Letβs consider the cylinder tilted by angle $\theta$ from the vertical. The base of the cylinder is inclined at angle $\theta$ to the horizontal. The water surface is horizontal. The angle between the base and the water surface is $\theta$.
Consider the line segment on the cylinder wall connecting the lowest point on the base circumference to the highest point on the opposite side of the top circumference. This line segment lies on the cylinder wall and spans a vertical distance H and a horizontal distance 2R (across the diameter).
The angle this line makes with the base is $\alpha$ such that $\tan \alpha = H / (2R)$.
The water surface is horizontal and contains this line segment when the cylinder is tilted to the maximum angle without spilling (for half volume).
The angle the cylinder axis makes with the vertical is $\theta$. The water surface is horizontal. The angle between the cylinder axis and the water surface is $90^\circ β \theta$.
The line segment on the wall connecting the lowest point on the base to the highest point on the top (on the opposite side) lies within the plane of the cylinder wall. The angle this line makes with the cylinder axis is $90^\circ β \alpha$.
The water surface is perpendicular to the vertical, and the cylinder axis makes angle $\theta$ with the vertical. The line segment connecting the points lies on the water surface.
Letβs re-examine the cross-section rectangle (width 2R, height H). The horizontal water surface cuts this rectangle.
The volume of water is $\pi R^2 (H/2)$.
The volume of water in a tilted cylinder below a horizontal plane cutting the cylinder is a wedge. If the plane passes through one side of the base diameter and the opposite side of the top diameter, the volume of the wedge is $\pi R^2 \times (H/2)$, which is exactly half the cylinder volume.
This configuration occurs when the angle $\alpha$ made by the line connecting the lowest point on the base and the highest point on the opposite top rim with the horizontal is $0^\circ$.
The angle of tilt $\theta$ from the vertical corresponds to the angle the cylinderβs side makes with the horizontal.
In the cross-section (rectangle of width 2R and height H), the line from (-R, 0) to (R, H) makes an angle $\beta$ with the *horizontal* axis (representing the diameter direction) such that $\tan \beta = H / (2R)$. This line is the water surface in this cross-section when the cylinder contains half volume and is tilted to the spilling point.
The angle the base makes with the horizontal is $\theta$. The water surface is horizontal. The angle between the water surface and the base is $\theta$.
The angle between the base (horizontal line in the upright cross-section view) and the line segment (-R, 0) to (R, H) is $\beta$. This angle $\beta$ is the maximum tilt angle $\theta_{max}$ of the base from the horizontal.
So, $\tan \theta_{max} = \frac{H}{2R}$.
Given H = 10 cm, R = 5 cm.
$\tan \theta_{max} = \frac{10}{2 \times 5} = \frac{10}{10} = 1$.
$\theta_{max} = \arctan(1) = 45^\circ$.
The cylinder is tilted so that no water goes out. This means the angle of tilt $\theta$ from the vertical must be less than or equal to the maximum angle before spilling.
So, the angle by which the cylinder is tilted is $\theta \leq 45^\circ$.
Option B states βnot more than 45Β°β, which means $\theta \leq 45^\circ$. This is the condition for no water going out.
β Volume of a cylinder.
β When a half-filled cylinder is tilted without spilling, the maximum angle of tilt occurs when the water surface connects the lowest point on the base rim to the highest point on the top rim (diametrically opposite).
β The tangent of the maximum tilt angle from the horizontal (or the angle between the base and the horizontal water surface) is given by $H/(2R)$.
β The tilt angle from the vertical is the same as the angle of the base from the horizontal.