Consider the following statements about the Dutch trade in Mughal peri

Consider the following statements about the Dutch trade in Mughal period :

  • 1. The Dutch transported silk goods from Bengal through Hooghly
  • 2. Cloves and nutmegs were collected at Surat by the Dutch and exported to Europe

Which of the statements given above is/are correct ?

1 only
2 only
Both 1 and 2
Neither 1 nor 2
This question was previously asked in
UPSC CAPF – 2024
Let’s evaluate the statements about the Dutch trade in the Mughal period:
1. The Dutch transported silk goods from Bengal through Hooghly: This is correct. The Dutch East India Company (Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie – VOC) had significant trading interests in Bengal, which was a major centre for textile production, including silk. They established a factory at Chinsurah (near Hooghly) and were actively involved in transporting silk, cotton textiles, saltpetre, and other goods from Bengal via the Hooghly River to their ships for export to Europe and other Asian markets.
2. Cloves and nutmegs were collected at Surat by the Dutch and exported to Europe: This is incorrect. Cloves and nutmegs were highly valuable spices originating from the Moluccas (Spice Islands) in Southeast Asia. The Dutch established a virtual monopoly over the trade of these spices by controlling their source in Southeast Asia. Surat was a major port for trade in goods from the Indian subcontinent, Persia, and Arabia. While the Dutch traded at Surat, their primary source and export point for Moluccan spices were Southeast Asian ports like Batavia (Jakarta), from where they were shipped directly to Europe or other destinations. Spices like cloves and nutmegs were not sourced or collected in significant quantities *at Surat* for export to Europe.
The Dutch were major players in Indian Ocean trade during the Mughal period, prominent in textile trade from regions like Bengal, but their spice trade monopoly was centered on Southeast Asia, not ports like Surat for export of Moluccan spices.
The Dutch VOC was a powerful entity that competed with the English, French, and other European companies as well as Asian merchants. They traded in a wide variety of goods across Asia, but their most profitable monopoly was initially in the spice trade from Southeast Asia.