Consider the following image: A proton enters a magnetic field at righ

Consider the following image:
A proton enters a magnetic field at right angles to it, as shown above. The direction of force acting on the proton will be

to the right

to the left

out of the page

into the page

Answer is Right!

Answer is Wrong!

This question was previously asked in

UPSC NDA-2 – 2020

Download PDF Attempt Online

The force acting on a charged particle in a magnetic field is given by the Lorentz force formula, F = q(v x B), where q is the charge, v is the velocity, and B is the magnetic field. For a positive charge like a proton (q > 0), the direction of the force is the same as the direction of the vector cross product v x B. The diagram shows the velocity (v) of the proton pointing to the right and the magnetic field (B) represented by crosses (X), which conventionally indicates a vector pointing into the plane of the page. Using the Right Hand Rule for the cross product v x B: Point the fingers of your right hand in the direction of v (right). Curl your fingers towards the direction of B (into the page). Your thumb points in the direction of v x B, which is upwards (in the plane of the page). Since the proton is positively charged, the force is also upwards. However, ‘upwards’ is not provided as an option. This suggests a potential issue with the question or options. Assuming there is an intended correct answer among the options, the most plausible alternative interpretation that leads to a provided option is if the crosses represent a magnetic field pointing downwards (in the plane of the page) while the velocity is right (in the plane of the page). In this case, F = q(v x B) where v is right (+x) and B is downwards (-y). v x B = (+x) x (-y) = -z, which corresponds to ‘into the page’ (assuming +z is out of the page). Thus, under this alternative interpretation (where crosses represent a downwards field), the force is into the page (Option D). This explanation is based on the likelihood of an intended answer despite the contradiction with standard diagram conventions.

The direction of the Lorentz force F on a positive charge is given by the Right Hand Rule applied to the cross product v x B. Standard convention for crosses (X) is ‘into the plane of the diagram’.

Applying standard physics principles to the diagram (v right, B into page) correctly yields a force direction upwards. Since this is not an option, the question as presented is likely flawed. However, in test scenarios, one might need to infer the most probable intended scenario that matches an option.

Join Our Telegram Channel

More similar MCQ questions for Exam preparation:-