‘A’ sues ‘B’ for a libel imputing disgraceful conduct to ‘A’. ‘B’ affirms that the matter alleged to be libelous is true. Which one of the following is not a relevant fact ?
Position of parties at the time when the libel was published
The relations of the parties at the time when the libel was published
Particulars of some dispute between A and B about a matter unconnected with the libel
Facts of some dispute between A and B which affected relations between them
Answer is Right!
Answer is Wrong!
This question was previously asked in
UPSC CISF-AC-EXE – 2020
– Facts forming part of the same transaction, facts showing motive, preparation, conduct, or relationship of parties are often relevant under Sections 6-16 of the Act.
– In a defamation case, facts related to the relationship, background, and circumstances surrounding the publication of the statement are relevant to understand the context and evaluate the claim and defense.
– A dispute on an entirely unrelated matter, without a link to the alleged libel, is generally considered irrelevant as it does not help prove or disprove the truth of the libel or the circumstances of its publication.
– Facts that provide context for the relationship between the parties (options A, B, D) can be relevant for various aspects of the case, including potential motive, the impact of the statement, or assessing damages, depending on the specifics.