Two pillars are placed vertically 8 feet apart. The height difference

Two pillars are placed vertically 8 feet apart. The height difference of the two pillars is 6 feet. The two ends of a rope of length 15 feet are tied to the tips of the two pillars. The portion of the length of the taller pillar that can be brought in contact with the rope without detaching the rope from the pillars is

less than 6 feet
more than 6 feet but less than 7 feet
more than 7 feet but less than 8 feet
more than 8 feet
This question was previously asked in
UPSC CAPF – 2018
The correct answer is B) more than 6 feet but less than 7 feet.
Let the height of the shorter pillar be $h_1$ and the taller pillar be $h_2$. The distance between the pillars is 8 feet. The height difference is $h_2 – h_1 = 6$ feet. The rope length is 15 feet. The rope is tied to the tips of the pillars.
Let the tip of the shorter pillar be A and the tip of the taller pillar be B. Let C be the point on the taller pillar where the rope segment from A first touches the pillar, and the segment from C to B is along the pillar. We are looking for the length of the segment CB, let’s call it $x$.
The coordinates can be set up as A at $(0, h_1)$ and B at $(8, h_2)$. C is on the taller pillar at $(8, y_C)$, where $y_C = h_2 – x$.
The total rope length is the sum of the length of the segment AC and the segment CB.
Length of AC = $\sqrt{(8-0)^2 + (y_C – h_1)^2} = \sqrt{64 + (h_2 – x – h_1)^2}$.
Since $h_2 – h_1 = 6$, this is $\sqrt{64 + (6 – x)^2}$.
Length of CB = $h_2 – y_C = x$.
Total rope length = $\sqrt{64 + (6 – x)^2} + x = 15$.
Rearranging the equation: $\sqrt{64 + (6 – x)^2} = 15 – x$.
Squaring both sides: $64 + (6 – x)^2 = (15 – x)^2$
$64 + 36 – 12x + x^2 = 225 – 30x + x^2$
$100 – 12x = 225 – 30x$
$30x – 12x = 225 – 100$
$18x = 125$
$x = 125 / 18$.
Calculating the value: $125 \div 18 \approx 6.944$ feet.
This value is greater than 6 and less than 7.
The model assumes the rope is pulled taut along the vertical segment of the taller pillar from the tip downwards. The point C can be at any height on the taller pillar. If $y_C < h_1$, the vertical difference is $h_1 - y_C$. Let $y_C = h_1 - \Delta y$ where $\Delta y > 0$. Then $x = h_2 – y_C = h_2 – (h_1 – \Delta y) = (h_2 – h_1) + \Delta y = 6 + \Delta y$. The segment AC length is $\sqrt{64 + (h_1 – \Delta y – h_1)^2} = \sqrt{64 + (-\Delta y)^2} = \sqrt{64 + (\Delta y)^2}$. The total length is $\sqrt{64 + (\Delta y)^2} + 6 + \Delta y = 15$. $\sqrt{64 + (\Delta y)^2} = 9 – \Delta y$. Squaring: $64 + (\Delta y)^2 = 81 – 18\Delta y + (\Delta y)^2$. $64 = 81 – 18\Delta y$. $18\Delta y = 17$, $\Delta y = 17/18$. Then $x = 6 + \Delta y = 6 + 17/18 = (108+17)/18 = 125/18$. The result is consistent regardless of whether the point C is above or below the height of the shorter pillar’s tip. The length of contact is approximately 6.944 feet.