Case Study 12:
Fiscal Deficit of country is increasing day by day and to curtail this, Finance Minister decides to merge several ministries and reduce personnel in the central Services by 20% so that government spending should be checked. But opposition party is hardly raising any objection as they are occupied with onion price rise issue. Media is too busy covering IPL and bollywood’s controversies.
Vasu, an employee in the Cabinet secretariat feels both Opposition party and media have failed to perform their ethical duty to inform citizens about matters of public interest. Therefore, he starts writing anonymous blogs and tweets to inform public about the negative consequences of Finance Minister’s austerity measures. Is Vasu doing the right thing?
Answer key points:
- Vasu is not doing the right thing.
- Role of public servant is to obey the will of the community- articulated through the elected members including the said Finance Minister.
- Public servant has to remain politically neutral. Vasu is crossing his limits by his anonymous blogs.
,
The role of the CEO in setting the ethical tone for the organization is important because the CEO is the person who sets the example for all other employees. If the CEO is not ethical, then it is likely that the rest of the organization will not be ethical either. The CEO should set clear ethical standards for the organization and should model ethical behavior in their own actions. The CEO should also create a culture of openness and transparency, where employees feel comfortable reporting unethical behavior.
Whistleblowing is important because it is a way for employees to report unethical behavior to the authorities. However, whistleblowing can be challenging because employees may fear retaliation from their employers. Employees who blow the whistle may be fired, demoted, or harassed. They may also be ostracized by their colleagues. Despite the risks, whistleblowing is often the only way to stop unethical behavior. Employees who blow the whistle should be protected from retaliation. They should also be given the Resources they need to investigate and report unethical behavior.
The ethical obligations of employees include:
- Obeying the law.
- Acting in the best interests of the organization.
- Avoiding conflicts of interest.
- Being honest and truthful.
- Respecting the rights of others.
- Acting fairly and justly.
- Being accountable for their actions.
The ethical obligations of managers include:
- Setting a good example for employees.
- Creating a culture of ethics.
- Providing training on ethical issues.
- Taking action against employees who engage in unethical behavior.
- Reporting unethical behavior to the authorities.
The ethical obligations of boards of directors include:
- Overseeing the ethical conduct of the organization.
- Setting clear ethical standards.
- Reviewing the organization’s ethical policies.
- Investigating allegations of unethical behavior.
- Taking action against employees who engage in unethical behavior.
The ethical obligations of shareholders include:
- Holding the organization accountable for its ethical conduct.
- Voting for directors who are committed to ethics.
- Asking questions about the organization’s ethical practices.
- Divest their Shares if they are not satisfied with the organization’s ethical performance.
The ethical obligations of customers include:
- Supporting organizations that are ethical.
- Boycotting unethical organizations.
- Speaking out against unethical practices.
The ethical obligations of suppliers include:
- Providing goods and services to organizations that are ethical.
- Refusing to do business with unethical organizations.
- Reporting unethical practices to the authorities.
- Working with organizations to improve their ethical practices.
The ethical obligations of competitors include:
- Competing fairly and honestly.
- Avoiding unethical practices such as price-fixing, false advertising, and bribery.
The ethical obligations of the media include:
- Reporting on ethical issues accurately and fairly.
- Investigating ethical issues.
- Reporting on the results of their investigations.
- Giving a voice to all sides of an issue.
The ethical obligations of government include:
- Regulating businesses and organizations in a way that promotes ethical behavior.
- Passing laws that prohibit unethical behavior.
- Enforcing those laws.
- Providing resources to help businesses and organizations comply with the law.
The ethical obligations of civil Society include:
- Holding businesses and organizations accountable for their ethical conduct.
- Advocating for ethical practices.
- Boycotting unethical organizations.
- Speaking out against unethical practices.
The ethical obligations of the international community include:
- Passing international laws that prohibit unethical behavior.
- Enforcing those laws.
- Providing resources to help countries and organizations comply with the law.
Ethics is important in the workplace because it helps to create a fair and just workplace. It also helps to protect employees from unethical behavior. Ethics is also important for the organization as a whole, as it can help to build trust and reputation.
Here are some frequently asked questions about ethics:
-
What is ethics?
Ethics is the study of morality and the principles of right and wrong. It is a branch of philosophy that deals with the nature of good and evil, and the rules and principles that govern human behavior. -
What are some ethical principles?
Some ethical principles include honesty, Integrity, fairness, respect, and compassion. These principles can be used to guide our decisions and actions in all areas of life. -
What are some ethical dilemmas?
An ethical dilemma is a situation in which there is no clear right or wrong answer. In these situations, we must weigh the different Options and choose the one that we believe is the most ethical. -
What are some ethical theories?
There are many different ethical theories, each with its own set of principles. Some common ethical theories include utilitarianism, deontology, and virtue ethics. -
What is the difference between ethics and morality?
Ethics is the study of morality, while morality is the set of beliefs about right and wrong that we hold. Ethics is a more abstract concept, while morality is more concrete. -
What is the role of ethics in business?
Ethics plays an important role in business. Businesses must make decisions that are ethical in order to be successful. Ethical businesses are more likely to attract and retain customers and employees, and they are less likely to be involved in scandals. -
What are some ethical issues in business?
Some ethical issues in business include bribery, discrimination, insider trading, and environmental pollution. These issues can have a negative impact on businesses, their employees, and the public. -
What are some ethical codes of conduct?
Ethical codes of conduct are sets of rules that businesses and organizations adopt to guide their employees’ behavior. These codes can help to ensure that businesses act ethically and avoid legal problems. -
What are some ethical challenges in the 21st century?
Some ethical challenges in the 21st century include the rise of Artificial Intelligence, the increasing gap between the rich and the poor, and the threat of Climate change. These challenges require us to think critically about our values and how we can live in a more ethical world. -
What is the future of ethics?
The future of ethics is uncertain. However, it is likely that ethical issues will become increasingly complex in the years to come. We will need to develop new ways to think about ethics and to address the ethical challenges that we face.
-
Which of the following is not a type of ethical dilemma?
(A) A situation in which there is no right or wrong answer
(B) A situation in which there is a conflict between two or more ethical principles
(C) A situation in which there is a conflict between personal ethics and professional ethics
(D) A situation in which there is a conflict between the law and ethics -
Which of the following is not an ethical principle?
(A) Autonomy
(B) Beneficence
(C) Non-maleficence
(D) Justice -
Which of the following is not a factor to consider when making an ethical decision?
(A) The consequences of the decision
(B) The rights of the involved parties
(C) The laws and regulations that apply
(D) The personal beliefs of the decision-maker -
Which of the following is not a way to resolve an ethical dilemma?
(A) Consult with an ethics expert
(B) Talk to the people involved in the dilemma
(C) Make a decision based on your personal beliefs
(D) Follow the law -
Which of the following is not an example of an ethical violation?
(A) Plagiarism
(B) Cheating
(C) Stealing
(D) Being late for work -
Which of the following is not an example of an ethical dilemma in the workplace?
(A) A manager is asked to fire an employee who is a friend.
(B) A company is considering a new product that could be harmful to the Environment.
(C) A doctor is asked to perform a surgery that he believes is not in the best interests of the patient.
(D) A teacher is asked to grade students on a curve, even though she believes that some students deserve higher grades than others. -
Which of the following is not an example of a professional Code of ethics?
(A) The Hippocratic Oath
(B) The Code of Ethics for Nurses
(C) The Code of Ethics for Journalists
(D) The Code of Ethics for Lawyers -
Which of the following is not a way to promote ethical behavior in the workplace?
(A) Create a code of ethics
(B) Provide training on ethics
(C) Establish a system for reporting ethical violations
(D) Discipline employees who violate the code of ethics -
Which of the following is not a benefit of ethical behavior in the workplace?
(A) Increased employee morale
(B) Reduced turnover
(C) Improved customer satisfaction
(D) Increased profits -
Which of the following is not a risk of unethical behavior in the workplace?
(A) Lawsuits
(B) Regulatory fines
(C) Damage to reputation
(D) Loss of customers